Hi. I’m Kim West, The Sleep Lady, and today I’m going to answer Ashley’s question:
“My 11-month-old has always been a terrible sleeper but she does well with naps. We put her down drowsy and she’ll toss and turn and fall asleep on her own most of the time. At night she gets sleepy around 7:30 p.m. She’s already eaten and had a bottle or a sippy cup and we’ll rock and swing her and when she gets drowsy I’ll put her in her crib.
“She will lie there for a few minutes and then she’s up standing and crying bloody murder. This happens about 5 times before she actually really falls asleep. During the night she’s up, too, and we do the whole thing over again. I tried cry-it-out for ten minutes and I am not sure if I should do it for longer. I’ll take any suggestions.
An 11-month-old needs on average about 11.25 hours of sleep at night and 2.5 hours of sleep during the day. The 2.5 hours for naptime is usually spread over two naps. Sometimes when we do nap coaching we have to add a third “bonus” nap so that your baby can make it to bedtime and not be completely exhausted.
Check the Nap Schedule
You didn’t say whether your baby is well-napped. You did say that she goes down well for the naps but I would want to check and see whether the timing of her naps are good and if they total approximately two and a half hours.
Start With Adjusting Bedtime
It sounds like she may be getting too drowsy at bedtime. What I mean is that if she is so drowsy that she nods off when put her in the crib because of exhaustion then she may not have mastered fully the skill of putting herself to sleep from a more wakeful state.
Remember that bedtime is the easiest time to learn how to put yourself to sleep. If you don’t have it mastered at bedtime, it is very hard to learn how to do that in the middle of the night. It is even more difficult if she also tends to have an an early rising and short nap struggles. So, let’s make some adjustments that will help her master the skill of going to sleep and back to sleep.
An Early Bedtime
I notice that you said “we’ll rock and sing and when she gets drowsy I’ll put her in the crib.” I would start there and adjust your bedtime routine.
I think you might want to consider an earlier bedtime because it seems like she may be sleep deprived from waking multiple times at night. Ideally you want to get her to bed during her magical bedtime window. The magical hour for her may be 7 p.m. which by that time she should have finished her bottle.
Drowsy But Awake
If she still seems too wide awake, you can read her a short book. If you wantto continue to sing a song because it’s part of your ritual, I would recommend you sing with the light on and not for too long. It is not your job or goal to get her more drowsy. Your goal is for her to be drowsy but awake. I define drowsy but awake as “I’m dry, I’m fed, I’m warm, I’m clean, I’m loved and now it’s time for me to go to into my bed.”
Awake is Better Than Too Drowsy
I think that as your daughter has become older and smarter, it is possible that she’s on to you. She may sense what is going on and think “Oh, yeah, you’re going to get me almost there, but not completely asleep, and then you’re going to put me into the crib.” She may feel a little tricked which may be why she is screaming, as you were saying. To avoid giving this mixed signal, I would put her in her crib more awake.
Decide on a Sleep Method You Can Live With – Consistently!
Decide on the sleep method that you feel comfortable with and that you can follow through with consistently. Since you’ve tried cry-it-out for ten minutes, which I understand is a long time to hear your child cry, you have nothing to lose by starting off with The Sleep Lady Shuffle.
You can always decide later to move faster through The Shuffle and start leaving the room and doing checks but you don’t have to start there.. The most important issue is to pick the method that seems the right match for your child’s temperament and that you can follow through with consistently.
Video filmed by In Focus Studios